I have located the manuscripts of diaries written by fifteen Puritan Ministers spanning the periods indicated:
Archer, Isaac of Mildenhall, Suffolk, 1659-1700
Bilby, William of Nottingham, 1714-1717
Chandler, Francis of Theydon Garnon, Essex, 1661-1666
Henry, Philip of Worthenbury, Clwyd, 1673, 1674-1687
Heywood, Oliver of Halifax, Yorks, 1665-1673, 1678-1682
Hussey, Joseph of Cambridge, 1681-1726
Josselin, Ralph of East Colne, Essex, 1640-1683
Larkham, Thomas of Tavistock, Devon, 1650-1669
More, John of Earls Croom, Worcs, 1694-96, 1698-1700
Newcome, Henry of Manchester, 1661-1663
Rogers, Samuel of Bishops Stortford, Herts, 1634-1638
Sampson, Henry of Framlingham, Suffolk, 1693-1698
Stockton, Owen of Ipswich, Suffolk, 1665-1680
Syms, John of Sheepstor, Devon, 1642-1649
Taylor, Timothy of Stockport, 1673-1676
The geographical areas include several English counties and one Welsh. I am surprised however to have found nothing suitable for my research from London, which generally provided the most diaries for the 17th century (McKay, p 207). The periods covered in the diaries are quite well distributed over my period of research (1640-1715), but I lack a diary covering the first decade of the 18th century.
Most of these manuscripts are held in the British Library or Dr Williams’s Library, and then others can be found in various county record offices or university archives. For the full bibliography, please see below.
Although, I had some suggestions from my director of studies, these diaries have not been easy to find. In most of the works I have read, the non-conformist diaries referenced are either pre-1640 (e.g. Samuel Ward, Samuel Rodgers) or turn out not to belong to ministers (e.g. Ralph Thoresby, Elias Pledger). The only helpful sources have been William Matthews’ British Diaries and Samuel Palmer’s The Nonconformist’s memorial. While Matthews’ 1950 text references diaries which are pretty sure to be available, Palmer’s work is a re-edition of Edmund Calamy’s An Account of the Ministers … Ejected or Silenced of the early 18th century and this has mostly provided a list of Puritan ministers’ diaries which I have not been able to find … yet.
The National Archives search engine has been particularly useful since it references documents available in many different archives; through this, I discovered those kept at the British Library. The manuscript collection held at Dr Williams’s Library is described in a pdf file, Ancient Manuscripts and Rolls, available on their web page, “Archive lists / Cataloguing progress” (http://dwl.ac.uk/view.php?&page=292).
If you happen to know the whereabouts of any other diaries written by Puritan or non-conformist ministers, please let me know.
Bibliography of Primary Sources
Archer, Isaac. Isaac Archer: Diary. 1659-1700. MS. CamUL. MS Add. 8499
Archer, Isaac. Typescript transcript of the diary of Isaac Archer, 1641-1700. 1659-1700. TS. ERO. D/DU 1642/9
Bilby, William. Autobiographical volume by William Bilby (1664-1738), nonconformist preacher, 1714-1717. 1714-1717. MS. NottsUL. GB 159 MS 140
Chandler, Francis. BIOGPAPHY of Nonconformists, by Joseph Hunter. 1661-1666. MS. BL. Add MS 24485
Henry, Philip. Diary. 1673. MS. Shrewsbury School.
Henry, Philip. Diary, cashbook and sermon notes. 1674-1687. MS. DWL. HENRY MSS 91 (10)
Heywood, Oliver. Diary of the Reverend Oliver Heywood. 1665-1673. MS. BL. Add MS 45965
Heywood, Oliver. Diary of the Reverend Oliver Heywood. 1678-1682. MS. BL. Add MS 45967
Hussey, Joseph. Hussey’s Church Book. 1681-1726. MS. CALS. R107/109
Josselin, Ralph. Microfilm of diary of Ralph Josselin, vicar of Earls Colne, 1640-1683. 1640-1683. MS. ERO. T/B 9/2
Larkham, Thomas. MS Diary of Thomas Larkham. 1650-1669. MS. BL. Loan MS 9
More, John. Extracts from diaries. 1694-96, 1698-1700. MS. BL. Add MS 25463 (15)
Newcome, Henry. Diary of Henry Newcome (1627-1695) of Cross Street Chapel. 1661-1663. MS. Chetham’s Library. Manuscripts/1/152
Newcome, Henry. Transcripts from the diary of Henry Newcome (1627-1695), made by J Sudlow, 1847 for Chetham Society. 1661-1663. MS. Chetham’s Library. Manuscripts/1/423
Rogers, Samuel. The Diary of Samuel Rogers (1634-1638). 1634-1638. MS. QUB. Percy MS 7
Sampson, Henry. Extracts of Day Books. 1693-1698. MS. BL. Add MS 4460 (6)
Stockton, Owen. Microfilm of diary of Owen Stockton, 1665-1680, and ‘occasional reflections’ of wife Elianor, 1695. 1665-1680. Microfilm of MS. ERO. T/A 526/1
Stockton, Owen. Observations and experiences of Gods dealing with my soul. 1665-1680. MS. DWL. Modern Folios 24.7
Syms, John. A DAY-BOOKE of some speciall passages and mercyes both personall and nationall. 1642-1649. MS. BL. Add MS 35297
Taylor, Timothy. Timothy Taylor (1612-1681) Presbyterian Clergyman. 1673-1676. MS. Yale (Beinecke Library). Osborn Shelves b 161
BL = British Library
CALS = Cambridgeshire Archives
CamUL = Cambridge University Library
DWL = Dr Williams’s Library
ERO = Essex Records Office
NottsUL = Nottingham University Library
QUB = Queens University Library, Belfast
Bibliography of Secondary Sources
Calamy, Edmund. The Nonconformist’s Memorial: being an account of the ministers, who were ejected or silenced after the Restoration. Edited by Samuel Palmer. Vol. 1, London: Harris, 1775.
— The Nonconformist’s Memorial: being an account of the ministers, who were ejected or silenced after the Restoration. Edited by Samuel Palmer. Vol. 2, Harris, 1775.
— The Nonconformist’s Memorial: being an account of the lives, sufferings, and printed works of the two thousand ministers ejected from the Church of England, chiefly by the Act of Uniformity, Aug 24, 1662. Edited by Samuel Palmer. 2nd ed., vol. 3, J. Cundee, 1803.
Matthews, William. British Diaries: an Annotated Bibliography of British Diaries Written between 1442 and 1942. University of California Press, 1950.
McKay, Elaine. “English Diarists: Gender, Geography and Occupation, 1500-1700”. History, Volume 90, Issue 298, 2005, pp 191-212.